Skip to content

A replayed or late-attached session draws a reply's reasoning frame from the reasoning blocks its logged llm_response carries, with no time to say; what streamed live still wins

TUI decision 174 · accepted · 2026-11-15 · issue #659 · supersedes 161

Issue #659, the terminal's half of reasoning on replay; the desktop app's is root Decision 999. TUI Decision 161 kept reasoning live only (after Decision 36): a log replayed had no deltas, so a session opened afterwards, or attached to mid-turn, drew no reasoning frame. This supersedes that sentence of 161.

The log has it. Root Decision 658 keeps a reply's reasoning as a block of its own in llm_response.message, and Translate dropped every block but text. It now keeps a reasoning block as %{type: :reasoning, text: …}, in either spelling (reasoning, thinking), and leaves out a redacted one, which has no words, and an empty one. Message.text/1 and tool_uses/1 never see it, so the answer and the headless printer do not fill with thinking. When an assistant_message folds and nothing streamed for that agent, the reasoning frame is drawn from those blocks; the frame's header is thinking alone, since the log says when the reply landed and not when the thinking began. When it did stream, the streamed text is kept, with its duration, as before.

Proof. test/troupe/frames_test.exs: a replayed turn whose reply carries reasoning draws ▾ thinking and its text at everything and its header alone at tools; the live turn still says thinking · 12s. test/troupe/remote_translate_test.exs: an llm_response keeps its reasoning block and drops a redacted and an empty one. Both failed on the branch's base.

Governs: clients/tui/lib/troupe/remote/translate.ex, clients/tui/lib/troupe/client/message.ex, clients/tui/lib/troupe/ui/tui/model.ex